The choice between positive displacement pumps and centrifugal pumps is a crucial decision in the design of industrial plants, process systems, and hydraulic applications. Both technologies have dominated the market for decades, but they address profoundly different needs. Understanding the operating principles, advantages, and limitations of each type is essential to optimize performance, energy efficiency, and operating costs.
In this article, we will analyze in detail the characteristics of positive displacement and centrifugal pumps, providing practical guidelines to identify the best solution for your specific application.
Operating Principles: Two Different Philosophies
Positive Displacement Pumps
Positive displacement pumps operate according to a simple yet effective mechanical principle: a variable-volume chamber captures the fluid and mechanically transports it from the suction to the discharge. This movement can be generated by pistons, gears, vanes, screws, or rotating lobes.
The key principle is that the fluid is “trapped” in discrete volumes and forced through the pump regardless of system pressure. This means that the flow rate is directly proportional to the rotational speed or movement of the pumping element, ensuring a constant and predictable flow.
Displacement pumps are divided into two broad categories according to ISO 4409:
- Rotary pumps (gears, vanes, screws, lobes)
- Reciprocating pumps (pistons, diaphragms)
Centrifugal Pumps: Kinetic Energy at Work
Centrifugal pumps operate according to a completely different principle: they transform the mechanical energy of the fluid into kinetic energy through the rotation of an impeller. The fluid enters axially at the center of the impeller and is accelerated radially outward by the centrifugal force generated by the rotation.
The kinetic energy acquired by the fluid is then converted into static pressure in the diffuser or volute of the pump. Unlike positive-displacement pumps, centrifugal pumps do not generate flow but rather head (pressure), and the resulting flow rate depends on the system’s resistance.
This principle makes centrifugal pumps ideal for moving large volumes of fluid at moderate pressures, but their performance is closely linked to the characteristics of their operating curve.
Distinctive Features and Performance
Positive Displacement Pumps: Control and Precision
Constant Flow Rate Regardless of Pressure
The most important feature of positive displacement pumps is their ability to maintain a nearly constant flow rate even when the delivery pressure varies. This makes them indispensable for dosing, mixing, and transfer applications where precision is critical.
High Operating Pressures
Positive displacement pumps can reach and maintain very high pressures, in some cases exceeding 500 bar for hydraulic piston pumps. This capability makes them ideal for hydraulic systems, high-pressure hydraulic circuits, and applications requiring significant pumping force.
Efficiency with Viscous Fluids
While centrifugal pumps dramatically lose efficiency as viscosity increases, positive displacement pumps maintain excellent performance even with highly viscous fluids. In many cases, volumetric efficiency actually improves with higher viscosities due to the reduction of internal losses.
Self-priming
Most positive displacement pumps can create the vacuum necessary to draw fluid even from positions below the pump level, without the need for priming.
Operating Limitations
Positive displacement pumps also have significant limitations. They cannot operate with the discharge closed against a closed valve without a safety valve, as otherwise the pressure would continue to increase until the weaker component fails. They are generally more sensitive to the presence of solid or abrasive particles that can damage the tight tolerances between the elements and seize them. Furthermore, many types cannot run dry without damage.
Centrifugal Pumps: Simplicity and Versatility
High Flow Rates
Centrifugal pumps excel at transferring large volumes of fluid. A single centrifugal pump can move hundreds or thousands of cubic meters per hour, making them indispensable for large-scale process applications.
Continuous and uniform flow
Unlike reciprocating positive-displacement pumps that generate pulsations, centrifugal pumps produce a completely uniform and continuous flow, ideal for systems sensitive to vibration or where process stability is crucial.
Simple construction
With few moving parts and a relatively simple design, centrifugal pumps are robust, reliable, and require minimal maintenance. The impeller is often the only component subject to significant wear.
Affordable cost
For low- to medium-pressure and high-flow applications, centrifugal pumps offer the best cost-effectiveness, both in terms of initial investment and operating costs.
Operation Against a Closed Valve
Centrifugal pumps can operate with the discharge valve closed without damage (within reasonable time limits), as they simply “whirl” the internal fluid, consuming power but without generating excessive pressure.
Operating Limits
Centrifugal pumps’ performance is highly dependent on their duty point. Flow rate decreases as pressure increases according to a specific characteristic curve. With viscous fluids, performance declines rapidly. They are not self-priming (except for special models) and require priming before starting. Finally, they are inefficient for low-flow, high-pressure applications.
Discover our centrifugal pumps >>
Energy Efficiency: A Complex Comparison
The question of energy efficiency has no single answer and depends strictly on operating conditions.
Centrifugal pumps achieve very high efficiencies (up to 85-90%) when operating near their Best Efficiency Point (BEP). However, efficiency drops rapidly when operating far from this point, as often happens in variable-flow systems.
Positive-displacement pumps maintain very high volumetric efficiency (95-98%) across a wide operating range, particularly with viscous fluids. However, they have higher mechanical losses due to internal friction, which can reduce overall efficiency, especially at low viscosities.
Rule of thumb: For high flow rates at low to medium pressures with low-viscosity fluids, centrifugal pumps are more efficient. For low flow rates at high pressures or with viscous fluids, positive-displacement pumps are the best choice.
Idropres equips its pumps with the latest-generation IE3 electric motors.
An IE3 motor means it belongs to the “Premium Efficiency” energy efficiency class, which is the highest of the classes established by the international standard IEC 60034-30-1 (IE1, IE2, IE3, IE4). This translates intolower energy losses and, consequently, lower electricity consumption and lower operating costs over time compared to lower classes.
Maintenance and Reliability
Centrifugal pumps excel in ease of maintenance. The most common operations involve replacing mechanical seals and bearings, which are relatively simple. Impellers may require replacement only after years of service, except in particularly demanding, abrasive applications.
Positive displacement pumps require more frequent and specialized maintenance. The pumping elements (gears, vanes, pistons) operate within tight tolerances and are subject to wear. Maintenance requires specific skills and the availability of appropriate spare parts. However, proper preventative maintenance ensures high reliability and a long life.
When to Choose Positive Displacement Pumps
Positive displacement pumps are the optimal solution in the following situations:
Precision-requiring applications: Additive dosing, proportional mixing, chemical injection, where flow rate accuracy is critical regardless of system pressure variations.
High-viscosity fluids: Heavy oils, greases, polymers, resins, chocolate, creams, where centrifugal pumps would be completely ineffective.
High process pressures: Hydraulic systems, industrial hydraulic circuits, applications requiring pressures above 10-15 bar.
Low controlled flow rates: When small volumes need to be moved precisely, such as in centralized lubrication systems or machine tool hydraulic circuits.
Shear-sensitive fluids: Products that degrade with the high turbulence generated by centrifugal pumps, such as emulsions, foams, or biological products.
Typical Applications: Hydraulic systems, lubricating oil transfer, chemical dosing, paint and adhesive pumping, food industry (creams, chocolate, yogurt), pharmaceutical industry, bitumen and asphalt pumping.
When to Choose Centrifugal Pumps
Centrifugal pumps are the ideal choice in these scenarios:
High flow rates at low to medium pressures: Transferring large volumes of water, aqueous solutions, and light fuels in industrial process, cooling, and firefighting applications.
Clean, low-viscosity fluids: Water, solvents, gasoline, and diesel fuel, where the fluid characteristics allow centrifugal pumps to achieve maximum efficiency.
Systems with pressure variations: Systems where pressure can vary without compromising process efficiency, and where absolute flow rate precision is not required.
Limited Budget: For standard applications where cost-effectiveness is a priority.
Ease of Operation and Maintenance: Where reliability is required with simple and infrequent maintenance.
Typical applications: Cooling and air conditioning systems, fire-fighting systems, industrial and civil water distribution, chemical process plants, fuel transfer, water treatment plants, irrigation.
Economic Considerations
The economic analysis must consider the Total Cost of Ownership (TCO), not just the initial cost.
Centrifugal pumps generally have lower initial costs and reduced maintenance costs, but can have higher energy costs if they do not operate at optimum performance. They are the economical choice for applications that benefit them.
Positive displacement pumps require a higher initial investment and higher maintenance costs, but offer superior efficiency in specific applications (high viscosity, high-pressure flow accuracy), which can offset lifecycle costs.
Recommended Analysis: Calculate the TCO over 5-10 years, including energy, maintenance, spare parts, and downtime, not just the purchase price.
A Strategic Choice
There is no universally superior technology: positive displacement and centrifugal pumps are optimized for different and complementary needs. The correct choice requires a careful analysis of multiple factors:
- Fluid characteristics (viscosity, temperature, presence of solids)
- Flow rate and pressure requirements (constant or variable)
- Required precision in flow control
- Operating conditions (ambient temperature, safety, available space)
- Budget and TCO over the system’s life cycle
A thorough technical assessment by industry specialists is essential to avoid costly mistakes and ensure optimal long-term performance.
